The Political is Personal

Jamie Willar

We are rapidly entering an era where is it becoming more and more acceptable to be openly lesbian, gay, bisexual, queer, questioning, and two-spirited. Members from the trans community are also making gains in terms of rights and representation; recently a hotline specializing in trans issues has even opened in Canada. Whereas there is progress being made for ensuring equal and equitable rights, there is still some backlash from pockets of society.

Whenever a professional athlete decides to come out of the closet (or to publically disclose their LGBTQ status), there are definitely mixed reactions from different segments of society. From the LGBTQ community, there is definitely jubilation. Representation in different institutions is a very important thing for all minorities, whether they are racialized or gender & sexual minorities. Queer youth need role models as well, and having ‘out’ athletes helps to inform queer youth that professional sports are open to them if they so want. Representation is about tearing down barriers for entry. When said barriers are torn down, there is more room for people to exercise their agency; there is more freedom because there are more viable options for careers, leisure, recreation, hopes, and aspirations. The world discloses itself to us by means of the choices we have. For most of my life and a good part of my adult life, I never thought that marriage would be an option for me. In 2005, Canada made gay marriage universally legal, and codified the constitutional right for gays to marry. An option that I never thought I would have has been readily available to me for the last several years, should I choose to act on it. Similarly, queer youth with a penchant for athleticism need to know that professional sports are an option for them as well; they do not have to choose to be who they are and having a career in a sport they are passionate about.

Potential backlash is a serious deterrence for athletes who may wish to come out. There is still social stigma associated with being LGBQT because there are harmful stereotypes associated with being as such. A gay man, who otherwise identifies as masculine may feel that masculinity as compromised because of the stereotypes surrounding gay men and effeminate mannerisms. Likewise, otherwise feminine women may feel like they will be stereotyped as ‘plaid-wearing’, ‘butch’ lesbians. When the entire purpose of coming out is to take command of one’s self-identity on one’s own terms, the stigma surrounding harmful stereotypes acts as an antithesis; one takes command of their self-identity only to be found powerless again when teammates, media, and society at large proliferates these harmful stereotypes. It takes the empowering aspect of coming out and attempts to negate it. The result is that far less athletes choose to come out, and instead remain silent. That is certainly their choice—but if a choice is heavily informed by the negative repercussions, the ‘goal posts’ have be moved by outside forces. The choice has been severely constricted. The second wave of feminism coined the phrase “the personal is political”—meaning that events that transpire in personal lives have a legitimate presence in the public arena. Likewise, the political is also personal: disruptive and harmful dialogues can have an extraordinary effect on people’s lives.


3 responses

  1. Awesome blog post, Jamie! You touched on some very interesting points.
    Mainly the restriction of stereotypes. People believe they have to conform to the accepted stereotypes of being a part of the LGBT Community. Years before finally coming out as bisexual, what scared me the most was that I felt like I would have to change into someone else, someone that “represented” what it meant to be a bisexual woman. I felt that I spent so many years trying to figure myself out, loving the parts of me that set me a part from everyone else and if I chose to come out, I thought I would lose all of that. It took me years to realize that coming out as a bisexual, didn’t change who I was. I’ve always been bisexual, it’s always been a part of me and made me who I was before coming out and I continue to be that person. But I was only one person, there was still a society of people that believed there was a specific definition of stereotypes that came with being a part of this community. I couldn’t change what they believed, as society had safety in numbers, so I waited years until I was ready to brave my own definition, regardless of what society believed. I guess my point is that these pre-conceived stereotypes kept me from fully expressing all that I am. This is also like the article I brought into class about gender and stereotypes; how the female chess players’ performances decreased by half when playing the male chess players, due to the anxiety and fear of the stereotypes already placed upon them, regardless of their skill level. Stereotypes can keep people from reaching their full potential, as people and in athletics.

    I think this all has to do with another point you mentioned, we need role models that tear down the barriers of stereotypes. We’ve been repeatedly exposed to those of the LGBT community that hold these specific characteristics. We need people of the public (athletes, politicians, actors, tv characters, etc.) that have their own identities to diminish the restriction of society’s beliefs. We’re now beginning an era that accepts differences from the norm; in regards to personalities, clothing, activities, etc. Why not take steps towards the LGBT Community too?

  2. Great post Jamie! The points you have mentioned I feel like are relatable to me. I was brought up in a society that taught me that the LGBT community is unnatural and same-sex acts are illegal; so the fear of coming out is strong. I didn’t conform to stereotypes portrayed by media (i didn’t wear plaid shirt nor was I a butch), I didn’t have a person to talk to growing up and thinking that you’re the only person that has this “issue” is confusing and depressing. Even my parents think that being homosexual is wrong and can be cured with religion and counseling.
    Coming to Canada took a whole lot of weight off my shoulders, I felt like I did not have to hide anymore and I could finally talk to people about it. In this society it has definitely entered an era of acceptance of the LGBT community.

Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s